Supreme Court: Dougherty Cops are "immune" from lawsuit

Jeremiah Fenn and O.D. Gilliam were involved in a crash that killed a man near Savannah in 2007.

ATLANTA — In a unanimous decision released Monday, the Georgia Supreme Court has ruled that two former Dougherty County police officers are immune from any civil lawsuit stemming from a car crash that claimed the life of a civilian near Savannah in 2007.

At question was the constitutionality of a state law that grants law enforcers with civil immunity for crashes that happen while the officers are in the course of their official duties.

“We are pleased that it came out the way that it did,” DCPD Chief Don Cheek said of the ruling Monday. “As long as officers are functioning within the guidelines, it is hard enough to do what we do without thinking: ‘Who’s going to second guess us?’”

While on their way to participate in Operation Rolling Thunder — an exercise to help curtail Savannah’s high number of traffic fatalities — Dougherty County police officers Jeremiah Fenn and O.D. Gilliam were involved in a car crash that claimed the life of Milton Wilcox.

The Wilcox family sued, saying that the officers were liable for the crash because of negligence. The family also sued challenging the constitutionality of Official Code of Georgia (O.C.G.A.) 36-92-3, which says that any local government employee who commits a “tort,” or wrongdoing, “involving the use of a covered motor vehicle while in the performance of his or her official duties is not subject to lawsuit or liability therefore.”

The court unanimously disagreed with the Wilcox family’s assertion and, in the opinion written by Justice Robert Benham, said that “simply because the Legislature chose not to extend immunity to counties and their employees in the [Georgia Tort Claims Act] does not mean that it could not do so elsewhere.”

“It is evident, then, that the Legislature had constitutional authority to enact (O.C.G.A.) 36-92-3,” Monday’s opinion says. “Therefore, we find that the trial court properly denied Wilcox’s claim that (O.C.G.A.) 36-92-3 is unconstitutional and properly granted summary judgment in favor of Fenn and Gilliam.”

Neither officer is currently with the department, but not because of the 2007 incident, Cheek said. Fenn is working with the police department aboard Marine Corps Logistics Base-Albany, and Gilliam has since left law enforcement all together.


bubbavet 3 years, 7 months ago



T_Paine 3 years, 7 months ago

This is ridiculous. The police need to be held to the same standard of driving as everyone else, and if they were not in pursuit of a criminal or rushing to the aid of a fellow officer (which they would not have been since Savannah is decidedly out of their jurisdiction) they should have been following the rules of the road. It would be no different than an officer on patrol hitting someone.

Police officers should be held just as accountable for failing to uphold the law, if not more so since that is their job. A 260 mile road trip should not count as "Performance of duty", and the officers involved should be held liable if negligence was indeed the cause of the crash.


Sign in to comment