The case against re-election

The stewardship case is pretty straightforward: the worst recovery in U.S. history, 42 consecutive months of 8-plus percent unemployment, declining economic growth — all achieved at a price of another $5 trillion of accumulated debt.

The ideological case is also simple. Just play in toto (and therefore in context) Obama’s Roanoke riff telling small business owners: “You didn’t build that.” Real credit for your success belongs not to you — you think you did well because of your smarts and sweat? he asked mockingly — but to government that built the infrastructure without which you would have nothing.

Play it. Then ask: Is that the governing philosophy you want for this nation?

Mitt Romney’s preferred argument, however, is stewardship. Are you better off today than you were $5 trillion ago? Look at the wreckage around you. This presidency is a failure. I’m a successful businessman. I know how to fix things. Elect me, etc. etc.

Easy peasy, but highly risky. If you run against Obama’s performance in contrast to your own competence, you stake your case on persona. Is that how you want to compete against an opponent who is not just more likable and immeasurably cooler, but spending millions to paint you as an unfeeling, out-of-touch, job-killing, private-equity plutocrat?

The ideological case, on the other hand, is not just appealing to a center-right country with twice as many conservatives as liberals, it is also explanatory. It underpins the stewardship argument. Obama’s ideology — and the program that followed — explains the failure of these four years.

What program? Obama laid it out boldly early in his presidency. The roots of the nation’s crisis, he declared, were systemic. Fundamental change was required. He had come to deliver it. Hence his signature legislation:

First, the $831 billion stimulus that was going to “reinvest” in America and bring unemployment below 6 percent. We know about the unemployment. And the investment? Obama loves to cite great federal projects such as the Hoover Dam and the interstate highway system. Fine. Name one thing of any note created by Obama’s Niagara of borrowed money. A modernized electric grid? Ports dredged to receive the larger ships soon to traverse a widened Panama Canal? Nothing of the sort. Solyndra, anyone?

Second, radical reform of health care that would reduce its ruinously accelerating cost: “Put simply,” he said, “our health care problem is our deficit problem” — a financial hemorrhage drowning us in debt.

Except that the CBO reports that Obamacare will cost $1.68 trillion of new spending in its first decade. To say nothing of the price of the uncertainty introduced by an impossibly complex remaking of one-sixth of the economy .

The third part of Obama’s promised transformation was energy. His cap-and-trade federal takeover was rejected by his own Democratic Senate. So the war on fossil fuels has been conducted unilaterally by bureaucratic fiat. Regulations that will kill coal. A no-brainer pipeline (Keystone) rejected lest Canadian oil sands be burned. (China will burn them instead.)

That was the program — now so unpopular that Obama barely mentions it. Obamacare got exactly two lines in this year’s State of the Union address. Seen any ads touting the stimulus? The drilling moratorium? Keystone?

Ideas matter. The 2010 election, the most ideological since 1980, saw the voters resoundingly reject a Democratic Party that was relentlessly expanding the power, spending, scope and reach of government.

It’s worse now. Those who have struggled to create a family business, a corner restaurant, a medical practice won’t take kindly to being told that their success is a result of government-built roads and bridges.

In 1988, Michael Dukakis famously said, ‘’This election is not about ideology; it’s about competence.” He lost. If Republicans want to win, Obama’s deeply revealing, teleprompter-free you-didn’t-build-that confession of faith needs to be hung around his neck until Election Day. The third consecutive summer-of-recovery-that-never-came is attributable not just to Obama being in over his head but to what’s in his head: a government-centered vision of the economy and society, and the policies that flow from it.

Four years of that and this is what you get.

Make the case and you win the White House.

Charles Krauthammer’s email address is letters@charleskrauthammer.com.


Kay523 3 years, 3 months ago

5 points: 1) Domestic oil production is at an all-time high 2) the majority of the stimulus was a GOP-loved tax cut - for two years 3) the second two years of his term, he has cut payroll taxes for everyone 4) Obama has had a string of foreign policy successes 5) It took us 10 years to climbout of the Depression; only 4 years under Obama


chinaberry25 3 years, 3 months ago

Look around you, we have never gotten out of the recession!


tywebb 3 years, 3 months ago

if you really want to debate charles krauthammer, i have 3 words for you......YOU ARE STOOOOOOOOPID!!!!!!


waltspecht 3 years, 3 months ago

Well, lets see. He cut payroll taxes at the expense of Social Security which had it's funding reduced by this measure, and possibly sped it's inevitable failure. He gave the Stimulas to friends and political croonies. Many of those receiving were known to be failing, and probably would fail. He gave the funding so his friends would fund their Golden Parachutes. Solera comes to mind. Foreigh success? Are you kidding, more Countries openly hold us in distain than ever before. He has stopped the oil pipeline and is working on stopping the cracking boom. There goes that oil production. He, and his programs are failures. He has found no middle ground to resolve issues, stubernly clinging to his master's choices. Plus I believe his wife is running him like a puppet. Tell us why he won't even release his college transcripts and records. I had to release mine for any job I applied for. What could there possibly be that he wants to hide? Could it be the fraud perpetrated to obtain the funds to attend school? Or could it be he proved he was a foreigh national to obtain ffunding?


chinaberry25 3 years, 3 months ago

Soon we will start the 40 days of prayer to, the 40 days before the election, to bring this country back to a Christian nation. BTY, what church has O attended. None, we know the answer. He finally made it to Camp David just before the election instead an expensive Hawaii vacation. If it is God's will he win, then so be it, the nation is the one who will really suffer. $500 billion will be cut in medicaid in Georgia next year. Woo! Hoo!


Sign in to comment